Lessons from “Chinese mothering”

Never have I experienced such a collective button being pushed than with Amy Chua’s revelatory story of how she raised her two girls the Chinese way. Is it the threat we feel when she throws western parenting under the bus? This is what happens to anyone of us when we feel blamed, disdained, or put down. We get defensive and either take it in as defeat or fight back. Exactly what our children do when we blame them. We are clearly getting our hackles up as she puts down what we do, especially what we have doubts about doing.

I just finished the book, and I must say I found her unabashedly honest about her dictatorial methods that would make the hair on anyone’s neck stand straight up—methods she says would be seen even as illegal in the western culture. I have a hard time believing that most Chinese mothers would say the things that Chua said to her girls. Her story points out many things we can learn from. Her girls are as different as night and day attesting to such different temperaments. Her oldest went along with and apparently agreed to go along with her mother’s style. It pushed her to reach her greatness. Her youngest took more than I would expect rebelling all along the way to which Chua’s very Chinese mother even gave warning. This daughter’s final straw came in public in Red Square in Moscow when she screamed our worst nightmare at her mother—a point to which she was driven by a mother who just would not listen.

It is important for all parents to hold high expectations of their children—as long as they can meet them successfully. But children are different. Not all can come in first or be the best. But even though her younger daughter could be the best, she didn’t want to be. The cost was too great for her—she was missing out on other aspects of a life she knew she would enjoy more. The question is what are after for our children? Is performance the key? Do we want our children to be the best at the risk of being a well-rounded person. So, yes, we should push our children to the point of “optimal distress” according to David Palmitter of Marywood University in Scranton, PA; not to the point of no return. It is important for children to be pushed or push themselves through a good deal of frustration, disappointment, and even defeat so they achieve true self-esteem through perseverance and accomplishment. But the push should not go so far as to cause such discouragement that a child gives up trying. Expectations need to be realistic and fit the child.

What Chua has that is evident is 100% belief in her daughters’ capability and strength. And 100% confidence in herself. This strength is a lesson we can take from this book. Western parenting falls short due to lack of self-confidence and trust in our children. When that dips, fears take over and loom large enough to fill us with doubt and inconsistencies. These trip us up every time. Chua’s strength and her evident love for her girls, which underlies all her retributions is what holds the family together.

I do believe that accomplishments of greatness can be achieved in a kind, respectful, non-blaming, and fully supportive environment. Let us find a balance. We can stand to gain a great deal more confidence in ourselves and our children while at the same time focusing on the importance of strength in relationship. I always want my children to see me as a source of love, support, and advice. That was always my barometer as I brought them up. Is what I am saying building or breaking connection? At 32 and 28, they still gain from that connection. I feel good about the strength of our relationships as well as proud of their accomplishments. We can find answers in moderation and balance without swinging to extremes.

5 thoughts on “Lessons from “Chinese mothering”

  1. What an eloquent response to this controversial book, Bonnie. Your question “Is what I am saying BUILDING or BREAKING connection?” can serve as a guiding principle for every parent every day.

    I’m picturing an engraved charm you could sell on your website! (I’m only half kidding…) Thank you for an important and memorable post.

  2. I’ve been bemused by all the fluffle concerning Tiger Mother. I think Bonnie’s point of many of us feeling threatened is the root of the intense reaction. What has comes up for me, a mother of four grandmother of seven, is that the helicopter and the tiger mother are not so far apart. It would seem either stance is filled with Mummy Ego…”Didn’t I do a good job?” From the view point of seventy four years, I see no more contentment and joy in folks who have “achieved” than folks who are just “average”. The bottom line, a point that Bonnie brings up over and over, is the value of embodying what we hope for our children. They are all different and will bump along paths as we have. My biggest gift to my four, I believe, has been transparency and integrity in whatever I do. As I watch them parent, build careers and relationships and be productive adults, this seems to be the commonality they all share. Achieve, maybe… good folk, no doubt!

  3. I am so glad I came across your site:-)

    I Love This:
    I do believe that accomplishments of greatness can be achieved in a kind, respectful, non-blaming, and fully supportive environment.

    I am going to make this the quote of the day in my house.

    Thanks for this wonderful post:-)…

Comments are closed.